I've not experienced judgment or criticism for adopting transracially yet. I wondered, back when we were on our first adoption journey, how our small, rural (white) community would react if we adopted a child of African American, Hispanic, or Asian heritage. The few locals we talked to about it had favorable responses, and since we've adopted Kiana, I've observed nothing but acceptance of her as a member of our family and community. Indeed, our little girl has the most crowded little finger I've ever seen as the entire community seems to be wrapped around that little finger! Our librarian reads her books at her every request, moms at Destry's ballgames bribe her with candy to come and talk to them, and all my friends adore her.
In fact, as I reflect back over the last nearly three years, I can remember only one incident that made the hair on the back of my neck stand up. It was very recently.
We were at one of Destry's ballgames, and a man standing behind me talked incessantly. I had never met him before, but to be perfectly honest, after listening to him go on for about an hour, I found him rather annoying. He barely stopped to breath in his jabbering, his conversation was mostly negative, and was liberally sprinkled with language I don't appreciate hearing at all, much less at a children's ballgame.
His young married daughter and her husband were showing their cute little black puppy to Easton and Kiana who were, of course, delighted. After some time, the daughter offered the puppy to her dad saying "Here, do you want to hold your 'grandson'?" The man replied "What would I want with a N. . .", then reached out and took the dog.
Shortly after this, I read Kevin Hofmann's book, Growing Up Black in White. You may remember my
post awhile back when I discovered his blog.
Kevin was adopted as a young boy in Detroit where racial conflict was a daily experience. Some hater, in fact, burned a cross in his family's yard when he was still an infant, and their church refused to accept that the family had adopted a Black boy. As a result, his family took such drastic measures as to move to a predominantly Black neighborhood where they would become the 'minority' and their son could develop security and identity in his ethnic heritage. This autobiographical book is quite interesting for those touched by transracial adoption, and it has opened my eyes in many ways.
I have to admit I was distracted by the typing/spelling and grammatical errors. If he publishes a second edition, I am tempted to email him and ask if I can edit/proof it first, because it was pretty bad. (chuckle) He also switched between past and present tense in a way that kept the book from flowing smoothly.
Having said that, it is still a book worth reading and I appreciate his candidness. He doesn't paint a rosy, happy, happy, joy, joy picture of adoption in general or transracial adoption--but then, that's just life, isn't it? Our choices have consequences, and sometimes those consequences involve sacrifice. This book raised my awareness level, and revealed some areas I need to be especially diligent about. I especially was reminded that we need to instill in Kiana a strong sense of her personal identity in God, her identity in her family, and her identity in who God made her to be to equip her for the challenges of life.
I can't help but wonder, as I ponder this book, what might Kiana say 30 years down the road? What sort of autobiographical book would she write to families who are navigating a similar road? Will she see us stand up to ignorance and racism on her behalf? I can't help but feel we might have failed her at that ballgame. I was sitting behind Alan in the bleachers, and I saw his shoulders stiffen in my peripheral vision as I whipped my head around to give the man an arched-eyebrow "EXCUSE ME?!" look. But that's all. Some situations might be more appropriate than others to say something--I don't know. But I feel more prepared for 'next time'--and sadly, even as I see and hope that our society is doing better in this regard, I expect there may very well be a 'next time'.
What do you think we should have done/said? Anything?